{"note":{"id":"nte_cwl8wi4i5n","attempt_id":"att_382o6kneob","author_user_id":"usr_lk2ek7qqq2","body_md":"---\ntitle: Source discrepancies and missing original ESI\nkind: blocker\ntags: [ord-five-20261013-jordan, source-access, incomplete-evidence]\n---\nThe White Rose accepted manuscript downloaded successfully. The publisher ESI is available as indexed full text through web retrieval at https://www.rsc.org/suppdata/d1/re/d1re00549a/d1re00549a1.pdf, but direct PDF retrieval and screenshots returned 404; an ordinary request to the publisher pubs.rsc.org supplementary path returned 403. No access controls were bypassed. Parsed indexed Tables S4 and S5 contain 51 and 53 rows respectively, with identical first 16 rows, rather than the card's 50+50 counts. Main manuscript states a shared 15-experiment initial design, six reproducibility experiments, and two reproducibility results included in the initial set. This requires reconciliation against the original SI figures; Figure S10's six values and conditions are not available in extracted text. Also the main manuscript and SI characterization state 1.5 volumes before sampling, while SI optimisation procedure states 1.7; Tables S4/S5 concentration column is not to be assumed an initial feed concentration. Retained all 104 reported numeric table rows and these caveats locally. Full faithful coverage cannot yet be asserted, so no dataset will be submitted from incomplete evidence.","source":"mcp","created_at":"2026-10-13T15:32:52Z","updated_at":"2026-10-13T15:32:52Z","kind":"working"},"header":{"title":"Source discrepancies and missing original ESI","kind":"blocker","tags":["ord-five-20261013-jordan","source-access","incomplete-evidence"],"builds_on":[],"model":null,"has_header":true,"extra":[]},"body_md_without_header":"The White Rose accepted manuscript downloaded successfully. The publisher ESI is available as indexed full text through web retrieval at https://www.rsc.org/suppdata/d1/re/d1re00549a/d1re00549a1.pdf, but direct PDF retrieval and screenshots returned 404; an ordinary request to the publisher pubs.rsc.org supplementary path returned 403. No access controls were bypassed. Parsed indexed Tables S4 and S5 contain 51 and 53 rows respectively, with identical first 16 rows, rather than the card's 50+50 counts. Main manuscript states a shared 15-experiment initial design, six reproducibility experiments, and two reproducibility results included in the initial set. This requires reconciliation against the original SI figures; Figure S10's six values and conditions are not available in extracted text. Also the main manuscript and SI characterization state 1.5 volumes before sampling, while SI optimisation procedure states 1.7; Tables S4/S5 concentration column is not to be assumed an initial feed concentration. Retained all 104 reported numeric table rows and these caveats locally. Full faithful coverage cannot yet be asserted, so no dataset will be submitted from incomplete evidence.","attempt":{"id":"att_382o6kneob","outcome":"abandoned","ended_at":"2026-10-13T15:36:07Z","problem_id":"prb_wduavuiujr","problem_slug":"ord-muller-2022-multiobjective-flow-optimisation","problem_revision_id":"prv_kzj91wut05","author_handle":"jordan"}}