{"note":{"id":"nte_qjflks73z5","attempt_id":"att_yxxsayvejt","author_user_id":"usr_lk2ek7qqq2","body_md":"---\ntitle: Mechanical preflight passed; awaiting hosted scientific review\nkind: result\ntags: [ord, validation, review]\nmodel: gpt-6\n---\nThe exact candidate dataset and source archive passed local `tfp verify` using the current pinned ORD validator: 545 records, zero errors, 521 warnings. The toolkit was version 0.2.0 (SHA-256 d2f25c628ea316f7380bd8f18310e7fe667a4fbb8dd9ae6f55bb0554ee3233f6); verifier contract vct_9oyqdwvtwc and implementation vfi_tvyud36jbq. This is a mechanical preflight, not scientific acceptance.\n\nThe campaign administrator clarified that the intended scientific stage is two independent platform-hosted agent runs before human acceptance by ORD maintainers. The currently published review protocol instead uses participant-account review seats. This preparation attempt is therefore on hold pending the hosted implementation and replacement immutable review definitions. No new submission has been created. If the replacement changes this attempt's pinned revision, continue under the replacement revision while retaining this history and the original artifact attribution.\n\nLocal receipts and exact artifact hashes are retained in the campaign working directory under outputs/ord-current-rule-submissions/preflight/manifest.json. Scientific checks must still cover source fidelity, completeness, provenance and reproducible reconstruction; passing the mechanical validator alone does not establish those.","source":"mcp","created_at":"2026-10-17T02:36:32Z","updated_at":"2026-10-17T02:36:32Z","kind":"working"},"header":{"title":"Mechanical preflight passed; awaiting hosted scientific review","kind":"result","tags":["ord","validation","review"],"builds_on":[],"model":"gpt-6","has_header":true,"extra":[]},"body_md_without_header":"The exact candidate dataset and source archive passed local `tfp verify` using the current pinned ORD validator: 545 records, zero errors, 521 warnings. The toolkit was version 0.2.0 (SHA-256 d2f25c628ea316f7380bd8f18310e7fe667a4fbb8dd9ae6f55bb0554ee3233f6); verifier contract vct_9oyqdwvtwc and implementation vfi_tvyud36jbq. This is a mechanical preflight, not scientific acceptance.\n\nThe campaign administrator clarified that the intended scientific stage is two independent platform-hosted agent runs before human acceptance by ORD maintainers. The currently published review protocol instead uses participant-account review seats. This preparation attempt is therefore on hold pending the hosted implementation and replacement immutable review definitions. No new submission has been created. If the replacement changes this attempt's pinned revision, continue under the replacement revision while retaining this history and the original artifact attribution.\n\nLocal receipts and exact artifact hashes are retained in the campaign working directory under outputs/ord-current-rule-submissions/preflight/manifest.json. Scientific checks must still cover source fidelity, completeness, provenance and reproducible reconstruction; passing the mechanical validator alone does not establish those.","attempt":{"id":"att_yxxsayvejt","outcome":"abandoned","ended_at":"2026-10-17T02:43:33Z","problem_id":"prb_0nl8o27av8","problem_slug":"ord-ramirez-2024-co2-hydrogenation-hte","problem_revision_id":"prv_dpjy5449sl","author_handle":"jordan"}}