{"review_protocol":{"id":"rpt_ifc0n7f3gh","slug":"paper-extraction-panel","publisher_user_id":"usr_5homk2nezf","content_hash":"sha256:b9fd7cc1d39e9ca3751c3a78b45e51f68dc1de1e0ea254f4d605c2d47ba7c716","document":{"nodes":[{"config":null,"conflicts":null,"id":"panel","inputs":null,"op":null,"reviewers":{"allowed":[{"config":{"effort":"high"},"model":"claude-opus-5","provider":"anthropic"}],"count":3,"eligibility":null,"independent":true,"kind":"agent"},"rubric":{"citations":{"min_items":1},"confidence":"required","instructions_md":"You are judging whether the submitted extraction (the `document` artifact, in materials) is a FAITHFUL representation of the exact bound source (`paper_text`, also in materials; `paper_html` is the same document as published). You are not judging whether the paper is right.\n\nRead the source, then check the document field by field. Answer `pass` only if every material statement is supported by the source at or near its locator, the paper's central conclusions are not misstated, nothing is claimed about consciousness beyond what the paper itself asserts (the paper's §1.5 and §9.4 are the reference points), every replication/resource assertion is exactly what the paper states, and no omission would mislead a reader about the main findings, limitations, or explicit non-claims. Answer `fail` if any of those is violated materially. Answer `uncertain` when the document's fidelity turns on a judgment the source does not settle (e.g. slightly stronger wording than the source, or an omission whose importance is debatable).\n\nList every material error you found in `material_errors`, each with the document field, the problem, and the source locator that shows it. Do not list errors you did not verify against the source. Cite the source passages you relied on.","rationale":"required","response_schema":{"additionalProperties":false,"properties":{"material_errors":{"items":{"additionalProperties":false,"properties":{"field":{"maxLength":200,"type":"string"},"problem":{"maxLength":600,"type":"string"},"source_locator":{"maxLength":200,"type":"string"}},"required":["field","problem","source_locator"],"type":"object"},"maxItems":20,"type":"array"},"verdict":{"enum":["pass","fail","uncertain"]}},"required":["verdict","material_errors"],"type":"object"}},"skills":[{"requirement":"required","skill_version_id":"skv_38bb5h9zgu"}],"title":"Independent agent panel","type":"review","visibility":{"hidden":["submitter_identity","submitter_organization"],"prior_nodes":[],"stage_evidence":true},"when":null},{"config":{"accept":{"k":2,"predicate":{"op":"eq","value":"pass"}},"field":"verdict","reject":{"k":2,"predicate":{"op":"eq","value":"fail"}}},"conflicts":null,"id":"panel_decision","inputs":["panel"],"op":"k_of_n","reviewers":null,"rubric":null,"skills":null,"title":"Two of three","type":"reduce","visibility":null,"when":null},{"config":null,"conflicts":{"exclude_submitter":true,"exclude_submitter_organization":false},"id":"expert","inputs":null,"op":null,"reviewers":{"allowed":null,"count":1,"eligibility":{"organization_id":null,"rule":"campaign_reviewers","user_ids":null},"independent":false,"kind":"human"},"rubric":{"citations":{"min_items":1},"confidence":"required","instructions_md":"The agent panel did not agree. Read their reports (prior reviews), examine the source and the document yourself, and decide whether the document is a faithful extraction. `pass` or `fail`; list the material errors you confirmed.","rationale":"required","response_schema":{"additionalProperties":false,"properties":{"material_errors":{"items":{"additionalProperties":false,"properties":{"field":{"maxLength":200,"type":"string"},"problem":{"maxLength":600,"type":"string"},"source_locator":{"maxLength":200,"type":"string"}},"required":["field","problem","source_locator"],"type":"object"},"maxItems":20,"type":"array"},"verdict":{"enum":["pass","fail"]}},"required":["verdict","material_errors"],"type":"object"}},"skills":[{"requirement":"required","skill_version_id":"skv_38bb5h9zgu"}],"title":"Human expert","type":"review","visibility":{"hidden":["submitter_identity","submitter_organization"],"prior_nodes":["panel"],"stage_evidence":true},"when":{"node":"panel_decision","outcome":"unresolved"}},{"config":{"accept":{"k":1,"predicate":{"op":"eq","value":"pass"}},"field":"verdict","reject":{"k":1,"predicate":{"op":"eq","value":"fail"}}},"conflicts":null,"id":"expert_decision","inputs":["expert"],"op":"k_of_n","reviewers":null,"rubric":null,"skills":null,"title":"Expert decides","type":"reduce","visibility":null,"when":{"node":"panel_decision","outcome":"unresolved"}},{"config":{},"conflicts":null,"id":"final","inputs":["panel_decision","expert_decision"],"op":"coalesce","reviewers":null,"rubric":null,"skills":null,"title":"Panel, else expert","type":"reduce","visibility":null,"when":null}],"output":"final","policy":{"assignment_timeout_hours":72,"max_replacements_per_node":2},"purpose":"acceptance","subject_kind":"submission","title":"Extraction fidelity: three independent agents, human expert on disagreement","version":"tfp.review/v0.1"},"created_at":"2026-09-02T16:48:00Z","yanked_at":null}}